When Trauma Disrupts Rest

You’ve been diagnosed with service-connected PTSD, and you’re receiving disability compensation. But there’s another problem: you can’t sleep. You lie awake for hours, vigilant and alert. When you finally drift off, nightmares jolt you awake. You wake exhausted, and the cycle repeats night after night. You might think this is “just part of PTSD,” but sleep disturbance in veterans with PTSD often meets criteria for a separate, ratable sleep disorder—and you may qualify for additional VA disability compensation through secondary service connection.

This article explains the PTSD-sleep connection from a psychiatrist’s perspective, the types of sleep disorders that commonly develop secondary to PTSD, the medical evidence supporting this relationship, and how to document sleep disorders for VA claims.

The PTSD-Sleep Connection: Why Trauma Disrupts Rest

Sleep disturbance is not incidental to PTSD—it’s a core feature. The DSM-5 includes sleep disturbance as one of the Criterion E symptoms (alterations in arousal and reactivity). But understanding why PTSD disrupts sleep helps establish medical causation for VA claims.

Neurobiological Mechanisms:

1. Hyperarousal and Threat Detection

PTSD involves chronic activation of the body’s threat-detection system. The brain remains in “alert mode,” scanning for danger even during sleep. This hyperarousal manifests as:

• Difficulty falling asleep: The mind won’t “turn off” because the brain perceives ongoing threat
• Frequent awakenings: Hypervigilance causes the brain to wake repeatedly to check for danger
• Non-restorative sleep: Even when asleep, the brain doesn’t fully enter deep, restorative sleep stages

2. Nightmares and REM Sleep Disruption

PTSD is strongly associated with trauma-related nightmares. These nightmares occur during REM (rapid eye movement) sleep, the stage associated with vivid dreaming. In PTSD:

• REM sleep is disrupted by nightmares of the traumatic event
• The brain may avoid REM sleep entirely, leading to REM sleep deficiency
• Fragmented REM sleep impairs emotional processing and memory consolidation

3. HPA Axis Dysregulation

PTSD involves dysfunction of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis, the body’s stress response system. This causes:

• Abnormal cortisol rhythms (cortisol should drop at night to facilitate sleep)
• Elevated nighttime arousal
• Difficulty initiating and maintaining sleep

4. Fear of Sleep

Many veterans with PTSD develop fear of sleep itself because sleep means:

• Loss of vigilance and control
• Vulnerability to nightmares
• Re-experiencing trauma through dreams

This fear creates a vicious cycle: fear of sleep → poor sleep → worsening PTSD symptoms → greater fear of sleep.

Types of Sleep Disorders in Veterans with PTSD

Veterans with PTSD can develop several distinct sleep disorders, each qualifying as a secondary service-connected condition.

1. Insomnia Disorder

DSM-5 Criteria:

• Difficulty initiating sleep, maintaining sleep, or early-morning awakening
• Present at least 3 nights per week for at least 3 months
• Causes significant distress or functional impairment
• Not better explained by another sleep disorder or substance use

In PTSD: Insomnia in PTSD is driven by hyperarousal, nightmares, and vigilance. It’s not “primary insomnia”—it’s secondary to PTSD and qualifies as a separate ratable condition.

2. Nightmare Disorder

DSM-5 Criteria:

• Repeated occurrences of disturbing dreams
• Rapid return to full alertness upon awakening from nightmares
• Nightmares cause significant distress or impairment
• Not attributable to substance use or another medical condition

In PTSD: Trauma nightmares are a hallmark of PTSD. When nightmares are frequent and severe enough to cause independent impairment (fear of sleep, exhaustion, inability to function), they qualify as a separate nightmare disorder secondary to PTSD.

3. Obstructive Sleep Apnea (OSA)

Diagnostic Criteria:

• Repeated episodes of upper airway obstruction during sleep
• Confirmed by sleep study (polysomnography)
• Apnea-Hypopnea Index (AHI) showing frequency and severity

Connection to PTSD: Research shows veterans with PTSD have higher rates of OSA than the general population. Proposed mechanisms include:

• PTSD-related weight gain from reduced activity and medication side effects
• Fragmented sleep from PTSD worsening OSA symptoms
• Shared neurobiological pathways affecting sleep regulation

While the direct causal link is still being studied, medical literature supports that PTSD increases OSA risk.

4. Hypersomnia (Excessive Daytime Sleepiness)

Some veterans with PTSD experience hypersomnia—excessive sleepiness despite spending adequate time in bed. This can result from:

• Non-restorative nighttime sleep due to PTSD-related fragmentation
• Sleep deprivation from chronic insomnia
• Medication side effects (sedating psychiatric medications)
• Depression comorbid with PTSD causing hypersomnia

Medical Evidence Linking PTSD to Sleep Problems

The medical literature overwhelmingly supports the PTSD-sleep disorder connection. This evidence is critical for establishing secondary service connection.

Key Research Findings:

1. Prevalence Studies

• 70-90% of individuals with PTSD report sleep disturbance
• Insomnia is one of the most commonly reported PTSD symptoms
• Nightmares occur in 50-70% of PTSD cases

2. Longitudinal Studies

• Sleep problems in PTSD persist even when other PTSD symptoms improve with treatment
• Poor sleep predicts worse PTSD outcomes and treatment resistance
• Treating sleep disorders improves PTSD symptom severity

3. Neurobiological Studies

• Brain imaging shows altered activity in sleep-regulation regions in PTSD patients
• Polysomnography (sleep studies) demonstrate REM sleep abnormalities in PTSD
• Hormonal studies show HPA axis dysregulation affecting sleep-wake cycles

4. Bidirectional Relationship

• PTSD causes sleep problems (the pathway for secondary service connection)
• Sleep deprivation worsens PTSD symptoms (poor sleep makes PTSD harder to treat)

This bidirectional relationship is well-established in psychiatric literature and supports secondary service connection claims.

Read about other secondary conditions related to PTSD

How to Document Sleep Disorders for VA Claims

Establishing secondary service connection for a sleep disorder requires specific evidence demonstrating both the sleep disorder diagnosis and its causal relationship to PTSD.

Evidence You Need:

1. Proof of Service-Connected PTSD

• VA rating decision showing service connection for PTSD
• Current PTSD rating percentage

2. Sleep Disorder Diagnosis

• For insomnia or nightmare disorder: Clinical diagnosis from a psychiatrist or sleep specialist documenting symptoms meeting DSM-5 criteria
• For sleep apnea: Sleep study (polysomnography) results showing AHI and OSA severity
• For hypersomnia: Clinical evaluation and possibly sleep study or Multiple Sleep Latency Test

3. Treatment Records

• VA mental health notes documenting sleep complaints
• Prescriptions for sleep medications (trazodone, prazosin for nightmares, etc.)
• Sleep clinic evaluations
• CPAP prescriptions for OSA

4. Independent Medical Opinion Establishing Nexus

This is the critical piece. You need a medical opinion from a qualified physician (psychiatrist for insomnia/nightmares, sleep specialist or psychiatrist for OSA) stating:

• You have a diagnosed sleep disorder
• The sleep disorder is “at least as likely as not” caused by your service-connected PTSD
• Medical rationale explaining the causal pathway

Example Nexus Statement:

“I have reviewed the veteran’s complete medical records, including documentation of his service-connected PTSD rated at 70%. Based on clinical interview and record review, the veteran meets DSM-5 criteria for insomnia disorder, characterized by difficulty initiating sleep, frequent awakenings, and early-morning awakening present 5-7 nights per week for over 3 years. Medical literature clearly establishes that 70-90% of PTSD patients experience sleep disturbance due to hyperarousal, trauma-related nightmares, and HPA axis dysregulation. The veteran’s insomnia developed after his PTSD diagnosis, and his sleep complaints correlate directly with PTSD symptom severity. It is my opinion, to a reasonable degree of medical certainty (greater than 50% probability), that the veteran’s insomnia disorder is at least as likely as not caused by his service-connected PTSD.”

5. Sleep Diary or Log (Optional but Helpful)

• Document sleep patterns over 2-4 weeks
• Track bedtime, time to fall asleep, nighttime awakenings, wake time
• Note nightmares and their frequency

This objective data supports the severity of your sleep disorder.

Key Takeaways

• Sleep disturbance is a core feature of PTSD, driven by hyperarousal, nightmares, and neurobiological changes.
• Veterans with PTSD commonly develop insomnia, nightmare disorder, and sleep apnea, each qualifying as a secondary service-connected condition.
• Medical literature overwhelmingly supports the PTSD-sleep disorder connection, with 70-90% of PTSD patients experiencing sleep problems.
• Secondary service connection requires proof of service-connected PTSD, sleep disorder diagnosis, and medical nexus opinion.
• Independent Medical Opinions from psychiatrists or sleep specialists provide the nexus evidence VA claims require.

How VetNexusMD Can Help

Dr. Ronald Lee provides expert psychiatric evaluations for sleep disorder claims secondary to PTSD. As a board-certified psychiatrist with extensive experience in PTSD and sleep disturbance, Dr. Lee delivers comprehensive Independent Medical Opinions that establish the medical nexus between PTSD and sleep disorders.

Dr. Lee’s IMOs include:

• Review of service-connected PTSD documentation and current PTSD symptoms
• Clinical evaluation for insomnia disorder, nightmare disorder, or other sleep problems
• Medical rationale citing psychiatric and sleep medicine literature
• Clear “at least as likely as not” nexus statements
• Assessment of functional impairment for VA rating purposes

Whether you’re filing an initial secondary claim for sleep disorders or appealing a denial, Dr. Lee’s psychiatric expertise ensures your evaluation meets VA standards.

Learn more about psychiatric Independent Medical Opinions or request a consultation today.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I get a separate rating for sleep problems if I already have a PTSD rating?
Yes. If your sleep disorder is sufficiently severe and causes independent functional impairment beyond your PTSD symptoms, you can receive a separate rating for the sleep disorder secondary to PTSD. This is called “pyramiding” when done incorrectly (rating the same symptoms twice), but if the sleep disorder causes additional impairment, separate ratings are appropriate.

Do I need a sleep study to file for insomnia or nightmares?
Not necessarily. Insomnia disorder and nightmare disorder are clinical diagnoses that can be made by a psychiatrist based on your reported symptoms and clinical interview. Sleep studies are required for sleep apnea diagnosis but not for insomnia or nightmares. However, a sleep study can provide objective data supporting your claim.

What if the VA examiner said my sleep problems are “part of PTSD” and denied a separate rating?
This is a common VA position. You can appeal with an Independent Medical Opinion from a psychiatrist arguing that your sleep disorder meets criteria for a separate diagnosis and causes functional impairment beyond your PTSD symptoms. The VA must consider this evidence.

Can sleep apnea be secondary to PTSD?
Research suggests a connection, though the causal mechanisms are still being studied. An IMO can cite medical literature showing higher OSA rates in PTSD populations and propose mechanisms (weight gain, fragmented sleep, shared pathways). Some claims succeed; others depend on the strength of medical rationale and your specific clinical presentation.

What medications are commonly prescribed for PTSD-related sleep problems?
Common medications include prazosin (specifically for trauma nightmares), trazodone, mirtazapine, or other sedating medications. Evidence of these prescriptions in your medical records supports your claim by documenting treatment for sleep problems.

—

VetNexusMD provides Independent Medical Opinions for VA disability claims. We do not provide psychiatric treatment or establish doctor-patient treatment relationships. For mental health treatment or sleep disorder treatment, please contact the VA or a licensed healthcare provider.