Expert strategies to challenge VA rating reductions and maintain your earned disability compensation
📋 What You’ll Learn
Receiving a proposal to reduce your VA disability rating can be devastating. After fighting for years to get your benefits, the VA is now threatening to take them away. But you have rights, and with the right strategy, you can fight back effectively.
Legal Protections
Multiple laws protect veterans from improper rating reductions
Time Limits
Strict deadlines apply – act quickly to protect your rights
Evidence Required
VA must prove sustained improvement to justify reduction
Understanding Rating Reductions
The VA can propose to reduce your disability rating if they believe your condition has improved. However, they must follow strict legal procedures and meet specific burden of proof requirements.
Types of Reductions
- Routine Future Examination (RFE): Scheduled re-evaluations for conditions expected to improve
- Review of existing evidence: VA reviews your file and proposes reduction without new exam
- Clear and unmistakable error: VA claims original rating was wrongly granted
Why Reductions Happen
Scheduled Reviews
Conditions rated as likely to improve are reviewed every 2-5 years
Work Activity
VA discovers you’re working and assumes improvement
Medical Records
Treatment notes showing temporary improvement
The Reduction Process
Proposal Letter Sent
VA sends notice of proposed reduction with reasons
Evidence Deadline
You have 60 days to submit evidence against reduction
Hearing Request
Must request personal hearing within 30 days
Final Decision
VA makes final decision after reviewing evidence
Fighting the Proposal
Request Your C-File Immediately
Get a complete copy of your VA claims file to understand their reasoning and identify errors in their proposal.
Gather Counter-Evidence
Collect medical records, nexus letters, buddy statements, and any evidence showing your condition hasn’t improved or has worsened.
Request a Hearing
Within 30 days, request a personal hearing to present your case directly to a VA decision maker.
Submit Written Arguments
Prepare detailed legal arguments citing VA regulations and case law that protect your rating.
Evidence That Wins
Medical Opinion
Nexus letter stating condition hasn’t improved or explaining why symptoms persist
Treatment Records
Ongoing treatment showing continued symptoms and functional impairment
Lay Statements
Statements from family/friends describing ongoing symptoms and limitations
Vocational Assessment
Expert opinion on continued occupational impairment
Common VA Mistakes to Challenge
- Single exam showing improvement: VA cannot reduce based on one “good day”
- Ignoring flare-ups: Failing to consider the cyclical nature of mental health
- Cherry-picking evidence: Focusing only on positive notes while ignoring ongoing symptoms
- Inadequate examination: Examiner spent minimal time or didn’t review full history
- Wrong legal standard: Using “improvement” instead of “sustained improvement”
- Violating stabilization rules: Reducing ratings that have been stable for 5+ years
Know Your Protection Rules
5-Year Rule
Ratings in effect for 5+ years require “sustained improvement” to reduce
10-Year Rule
Service connection cannot be severed after 10 years (except fraud)
20-Year Rule
Ratings at same level for 20 years are protected from reduction
Age 55 Rule
Veterans 55+ are generally protected from certain reductions
Financial Impact of Reductions
Beyond the direct compensation loss, reductions can affect:
- Eligibility for healthcare priority groups
- Access to vocational rehabilitation
- State-specific veteran benefits
- Property tax exemptions
- Education benefits for dependents
If Your Rating Is Reduced
File Notice of Disagreement
You have one year from the decision date to appeal the reduction.
Continue Treatment
Maintain regular treatment to document ongoing symptoms for your appeal.
Gather New Evidence
Obtain updated medical opinions and continue documenting functional impact.
Consider Legal Help
Complex reduction cases often benefit from experienced VA attorneys.
Prevention Strategies
Consistent Treatment
Regular mental health appointments create protective documentation
Honest Reporting
Always report bad days along with good days to providers
Document Everything
Keep a symptom journal and save all medical records
✓
Key Takeaways
-
→
You have 60 days to respond to a proposed reduction – act immediately -
→
The VA must prove sustained improvement, not just temporary improvement -
→
Multiple protection rules may prevent reduction based on how long you’ve had your rating -
→
Strong medical evidence and legal arguments can defeat most proposed reductions -
→
If reduced, you have appeal rights – don’t give up -
→
Prevention through consistent treatment and documentation is your best defense
Facing a Rating Reduction? Get Expert Help
Dr. Ronald Lee can provide a comprehensive nexus letter addressing why your mental health condition hasn’t improved and continues to warrant your current rating.
Disclaimer: This information is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Each case is unique, and outcomes depend on individual circumstances. Consult with a qualified representative for advice specific to your situation.
